The European Commission has launched a formal investigation into Luxembourg's tax treatment of McDonald's and said that its preliminary view is that a tax ruling granted to the company may have afforded it advantageous tax treatment in breach of European Union (EU) state aid rules.
The Commission said that on the basis of two tax rulings given by the Luxembourg authorities in 2009, McDonald's Europe Franchising has paid no corporate tax in Luxembourg in the years since. It has however derived profits from royalties paid by franchisees operating restaurants in Europe and Russia for the right to use the McDonald's brand and associated services. The company's head office in Luxembourg is designated as responsible for the company's strategic decision making, and McDonald's also has branches in Switzerland and the US. The royalties received by the company are transferred internally to the US branch, the Commission said.
In 2014, the Commission requested information on these rulings. It said that its assessment has so far shown that it has been possible for McDonald's to reduce its corporate tax liabilities in Luxembourg and the US because the first tax ruling (provided by Luxembourg in March 2009) confirmed that McDonald's Europe Franchising was not due to pay corporate tax in Luxembourg on the grounds that the profits were to be subject to taxation in the US. This was justified by reference to the Luxembourg-US double taxation agreement. The ruling required McDonald's to submit proof every year that the royalties were declared and subject to tax in the US and Switzerland.
A second ruling was issued by Luxembourg in September 2009 after McDonald's clarified that McDonald's Europe Franchising did not have a taxable presence in the US under US law and could not therefore provide proof that the profits were subject to tax in the US. Under the second ruling, McDonald's was not required to prove that the income was subject to taxation in the US.
According to the Commission, "with the second ruling, Luxembourg authorities accepted to exempt almost all of McDonald's Europe Franchising's income from taxation in Luxembourg." It said: "As a result, the Luxembourg authorities recognized the McDonald's Europe Franchising's US branch as the place where most of their profits should be taxed, whilst US tax authorities did not recognize it. The Luxembourg authorities therefore exempted the profits from taxation in Luxembourg, despite knowing that they in fact were not subject to tax in the US."
The Commission will now investigate further to see if its concerns are justified, in particular the concern that the second ruling provided McDonald's with a favorable tax treatment in breach of EU state aid rules. It will assess whether Luxembourg authorities selectively deviated from the provisions of their national tax law and the Luxembourg-US double taxation treaty, and whether the Luxembourg authorities gave McDonald's an advantage not available to other companies in a comparable factual and legal situation.
Tax Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said: "A tax ruling that agrees to McDonald's paying no tax on their European royalties either in Luxembourg or in the US has to be looked at very carefully under EU state aid rules. The purpose of double taxation treaties between countries is to avoid double taxation – not to justify double non-taxation."
According to Article 107(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, state aid that affects trade between EU member states and threatens to distort competition by favoring certain undertakings is in principle incompatible with the EU single market.
In a statement, the Luxembourg Finance Ministry said: "The adoption of the opening decision is a procedural step that does not pre-judge the outcome of the investigation. This procedure is not related to any other case that is currently open. Luxembourg considers that no special tax treatment nor selective advantage have been granted to McDonald's. Luxembourg will fully cooperate with the Commission in the investigation."
In a statement provided to the BBC, McDonald's stated: "We are subject to the same tax laws as other companies and are confident that the inquiry will be resolved favorably. McDonald's complies with all tax laws and rules in Europe and pays a significant amount of corporate income tax. In fact, from 2010-2014, the McDonald's companies paid more than USD2.1bn just in corporate taxes in the European Union, with an average tax rate of almost 27 percent."
Treaty Update: Spain - Finland
According to preliminary media reports, Spain's Cabinet on October 6, 2017, approved the signing of a DTA and accompanying Protocol with Finland.
Treaty Update: Russia - Japan
Russia and Japan signed a DTA on September 7, 2017.
Treaty Update: Isle of Man - Turkey
A new TIEA between the Isle of Man and Turkey entered into force on October 7, 2017.
Treaty Update: United Kingdom - Belarus
The United Kingdom and Belarus signed a DTA on September 26, 2017.
Treaty Update: Morocco - Togo
According to preliminary reports, Morocco intends to launch DTA negotiations with Togo.
Treaty Update: Morocco - Bahrain
Morocco on September 21, 2017, published a notice in its Official Gazette to ratify and bring into effect the DTA Protocol signed with Bahrain in April 2016.
Treaty Update: Luxembourg - Sri Lanka
At a meeting on September 27, 2017, Luxembourg and Sri Lanka committed to expediting the negotiation of a Protocol to their double tax agreement.
Treaty Update: Burkina Faso - Turkey
Burkina Faso and Turkey initialed a DTA at the conclusion of three-day negotiations on September 22, 2017.
Treaty Update: Kuwait - Turkey
Kuwait and Turkey signed a DTA Protocol on September 15, 2017.
Treaty Update: South Africa - Cameroon
An order to bring into force South Africa's DTA with Cameroon was published in the nation's Official Gazette on September 1, 2017.
Treaty Update: Paraguay - Uruguay
Paraguay and Uruguay signed a DTA on September 8, 2017.
Treaty Update: Spain - Paraguay
According to preliminary media reports, Spain and Paraguay are to relaunch DTA negotiations.
Treaty Update: Liechtenstein - Monaco
Liechtenstein's Government has approved a double taxation agreement with Monaco, according to an August 23 announcement.
Treaty Update: South Africa - Cameroon
South Africa on September 1 confirmed that a new DTA with Cameroon entered into force on July 13, 2017.
Treaty Update: Thailand - Cambodia
Thailand and Cambodia signed a DTA on September 7, 2017.
Treaty Update: Brazil - Paraguay
Brazil and Paraguay agreed on the need to negotiate a DTA at a high-level meeting on August 21, 2017.
Treaty Update: Estonia - Japan
According to preliminary media reports, Estonia on August 24, 2017, approved the signing of a DTA with Japan.
Treaty Update: Switzerland - Zambia
Switzerland and Zambia signed a DTA on August 29, 2017.
Treaty Update: Hong Kong - Saudi Arabia
Hong Kong and Saudi Arabia signed a DTA on August 24, 2017.
Treaty Update: New Zealand - China
New Zealand and China held a second round of DTA negotiations on August 14.
Treaty Update: New Zealand - India
New Zealand is taking the necessary steps to bring its new DTA Protocol with India into effect, the Government said.
Treaty Update: Croatia - United Arab Emirates
Croatia and the United Arab Emirates signed a DTA on July 13, 2017.
Treaty Update: Canada - Grenada
Canada and Grenada signed a TIEA on July 14, 2017.
Treaty Update: United Arab Emirates - Cameroon
The United Arab Emirates and Cameroon signed a DTA on July 16, 2017.
Treaty Update: Grenada - Canada
Grenada announced the signing of a TIEA with Canada on July 17, 2017.